Dining out is such an essential part of any romantic getaway; some of the best bonding happens when enjoying delicious food and even better cocktails! Thankfully, there is a lovely selection of restaurants in Mercer County, PA, to add to your itinerary during your visit. From elegant multi-course dinners to casual walk-up counters, you’ll find great lunch and dinner options in Sharon and in the nearby small towns.
One of our favorite recommendations for culinary-minded guests is our sister property, Tara – A County Inn. Not only is this beautiful property just ten minutes away from downtown Sharon, PA, but it has two delightful eateries for your romantic date nights or group outings on the town. If you’re planning ahead, Ashley’s Fine Dining Room offers a five-course prix-fixe menu, while Stonewall’s Tavern has a large traditional menu with hearty steaks and seafood mains. Both are known for kind service and welcoming atmospheres!
After exploring the restaurants in Mercer County, there’s no better place to return than your elegant guest room at Buhl Mansion, one of the most romantic Boutique Hotels in Sharon. Perched on a hill overlooking the downtown area, this historic castle design is an iconic landmark. With on-site spa services and a morning breakfast (included with your lodging), it’s one of the best places to stay, especially if you’re seeking some private romantic time with your partner. Check out our upcoming availability and book your room today!
The Best Restaurants in Mercer County, PA for Dining
Enjoy the Dining and Drink Options at Tara – A Country Inn | Clark, PA
Guests at Buhl Mansion and the public can enjoy the dining offerings at Tara – A Country Inn. For a casual experience, you can opt for Stonewall’s Tavern. This pub-style restaurant is an excellent choice for those looking to relax and unwind in a charming and old-world atmosphere. The tavern sits in the lower level of the inn with its original stone walls.
There is a trap door, believed to have once aided the escape of slaves as part of the Underground Railroad in the 19th century. Be transported back in time by the hand-hewn beam ceilings and original stone walls, then lead into the trap door. Indulge in steaks, fresh seafood, poultry, and vegetarian options. You will also love the decadent desserts and scrumptious appetizers.
Tara – A Country Inn also offers Sunday Brunch and Holiday Buffets that are second to none in western PA. Please call for a reservation: 724-670-3099. Guests of Buhl Mansion will receive 10% off their orders. Reservations are required.
Vey’s Pub & Grille | Hermitage, PA
Offering live music several nights a month, along with a full menu, weekly specials, and a full bar, you will love the variety. Vey’s Pub features everything from classic Americana fare to unique gourmet selections. They are open for lunch and dinner. You will also find that they are open late on the weekends if you are looking for somewhere fun after most places close.
Rachel’s Roadhouse | Mercer, PA
If you are looking for excellent steaks, seafood, salad, burgers, and sandwiches, then you will love the impressive menu at Rachel’s Roadhouse. Established in 1983, this restaurant also offers a wide selection of on-tap beer. You will love the year-round patio bar or the cozy interior dining experience. They are open for lunch and dinner. You will have to visit to see why visitors and locals name this as one of the best restaurants in Mercer County, PA.
Talbot’s Taproom & Terrace | Mercer, PA
This unique restaurant offers a wonderful outdoor space for your dining pleasure. Proclaimed as a small “chef-inspired and people-driven” establishment, Talbot’s Taproom & Terrace strives to connect with their customers in an effort to enhance each personal experience. With a variety of on-tap beers and a specials menu that rotates every few weeks, there is something for everyone. Their menu is recently updated and features everything from an “Always Sunny in Philadelphia” Bowl to crab cake sandwiches and a variety of inspired entrees. They are open for lunch and dinner.
Haitian Sensation | Sharon, PA
This cafe with a cause offers Caribbean cuisine and delicious Haitian Mountain Bleu coffee. They have several specials that you will want to try. From a pulled pork sandwich for lunch to a jerk chicken or fish dinner, when you dine or sip at Haitian Sensation, you are “Helping Heal Haiti one cup at a time.” You get to be a part of improving the lives of those in Haiti.
Muscarella’s | Sharpsville, PA
Enjoy fine Italian dining in the heart of Shenango Valley. With an elegant atmosphere, delicious offerings, the freshest ingredients, and the finest staff, Muscarella’s is sure to please. They have been serving the community and guests with authentic Italian recipes for twenty-five years. See why they are raising the culinary standard in Mercer County, PA.
Maennerchor Club | Sharon, PA
Housed in a restored space that reflects its early 1900s roots, the Maennerchor Club is one of the last remaining German cultural clubs in the Shenango Valley, offering a lively atmosphere with live music, community events, and a traditional bierstube feel. Food here leans heavily into authentic German comfort cuisine with a modern, approachable twist. The menu features classics like bratwurst, schnitzel, and weisswurst, often served with sides such as sauerkraut, red cabbage, and house-made potato salad.
Stay at one of the Most Romantic Boutique Hotels in Sharon, PA
Now that you have a list of a few of the best restaurants in Mercer County, PA, you’re ready to make great dining decisions during your next stay at our romantic Boutique Hotel in Sharon. If you have not already booked your next retreat to our luxurious mansion, where relaxation and respite abound, then now is the time. We’ll start your day with a delicious breakfast, made fresh and served in our sunroom or delivered right to your door.
Many of our guests choose to book an early massage or treatment at our world-class, luxurious spa on-site and then head out to explore the area for lunch and dinner. This is just a taste of what you can expect when you visit Buhl Mansion and our surrounding area. We can’t wait to host you; book your lodging today!
